We research all the brands mentioned and may receive a fee from our partners. Research and financial concerns may impact how brands are presented. Not every brand is included. Learn more.
New York is a major financial hub with numerous reputable gold dealers offering investment-grade bullion, numismatic coins, and IRA-approved precious metals. Whether you’re looking to buy gold for a self-directed IRA or as a hedge against inflation, choosing the right dealer is essential. Below is a ranked list of the best gold dealers in New York for 2025, evaluated based on reputation, transparency, and customer service.
Find the Best Gold IRA Company of Your State
1. Augusta Precious Metals – Best Overall
Why It Stands Out: Augusta Precious Metals is the top choice for New York investors due to its transparent pricing, exceptional educational resources, and high customer satisfaction.
- Overview: Established in 2012, Augusta Precious Metals specializes in Gold and Silver IRAs. Their focus on investor education and lifetime customer support makes them an excellent choice for long-term investors.
- Pros:
- No-pressure sales approach
- Transparent pricing with no hidden fees
- Lifetime customer support
- Extensive educational resources
- Cons:
- High minimum investment requirement
- Limited selection of non-IRA metals
Get Augusta’s Free Gold IRA Kit
Schedule a One-on-One Web Conference with a Harvard-educated Economist
2. Goldencrest Metals – Best for Customer Service
Why It Stands Out: Goldencrest Metals has earned recognition for its exceptional customer service and investor-friendly policies.
Overview: Although Goldencrest Metals is a relatively new player in the Silver IRA industry, it has quickly established itself as a company that prioritizes customer satisfaction. Each investor is assigned a dedicated account manager who assists with every step of the investment process, from setting up an IRA to selecting silver assets. Goldencrest Metals is known for its fast response times, ensuring investors have all the necessary information to make informed decisions. The company’s dedication to fair pricing and customer education makes it a reliable option for silver investors.
Pros:
- Dedicated customer support team
- Competitive pricing on silver and gold
- Easy and fast IRA rollover process
- Focus on long-term customer relationships
Cons:
- Limited investment options compared to older firms
- Newer company with a shorter track record
Get Free Silver With Your Gold IRA
Connect with One of the Fastest Growing Gold IRA Providers of the US
3. Preserve Gold – Best for Customer Service
Why It Stands Out: Preserve Gold has quickly gained recognition for its outstanding customer support and personalized service, making it a strong choice for New York investors.
- Overview: A newer player in the gold investment industry, Preserve Gold assigns each client a dedicated account manager who ensures a smooth buying experience. Their strong customer support and quick response times set them apart.
- Pros:
- Dedicated customer support team
- Competitive pricing on gold and silver
- Easy and fast IRA rollover process
- Focus on long-term customer relationships
- Cons:
- Limited investment options compared to older firms
- Newer company with a shorter track record
Get Dr. Phil’s Endorsed Gold IRA Kit
Also, get a free safe for storing your gold with Preserve Gold
4. Noble Gold – Best for New Investors
Why It Stands Out: Noble Gold provides a beginner-friendly experience, making it a great choice for those new to investing in precious metals.
- Overview: Founded in 2016, Noble Gold offers a low minimum investment requirement and a wide selection of precious metals, including IRS-approved bullion. Their secure storage solutions in New York and other locations make them an attractive option.
- Pros:
- Low minimum investment requirement
- Wide range of precious metals
- Secure New York-based storage options
- Strong customer service reputation
- Cons:
- Pricing details not always transparent online
- Fewer investment options than larger competitors
Get Kevin Sorbo’s Gold IRA Kit
Connect with One of the Most Promising Gold IRA Companies in the Nation
Honorable Mentions – Top Local Bullion Dealers in New York
For investors looking for local gold dealers in New York, these bullion dealers are well-known for their reliability and selection:
- Manhattan Gold & Silver (New York, NY) – A trusted name for buying and selling precious metals in the heart of NYC.
- American Precious Metals Exchange (New York, NY) – Offers a wide variety of bullion and numismatic coins.
- Bullion Exchanges (New York, NY) – A reputable dealer providing a range of gold, silver, and platinum products.
- NY Gold Co. (Queens, NY) – A well-reviewed dealer with a diverse selection of bullion and investment-grade metals.
- Stack’s Bowers (New York, NY) – A well-established dealer known for rare coins and investment bullion.
Rules for Buying Gold and Silver in New York
Investing in gold and silver in New York comes with specific regulations that investors should be aware of:
- Sales Tax on Gold and Silver
- New York imposes a sales tax on gold and silver purchases unless they meet specific exemptions.
- Purchases over $1,000 of investment-grade bullion (gold, silver, platinum, and palladium) are exempt from sales tax.
- Numismatic coins and jewelry do not qualify for the sales tax exemption and are subject to local sales tax rates.
- Reporting Requirements
- Large transactions exceeding $10,000 in cash require dealers to file IRS Form 8300.
- Certain transactions involving large quantities of gold and silver may trigger federal reporting under anti-money laundering laws.
- Storage Regulations
- Investors can store their precious metals at home or use a private vault, but IRS regulations require Gold and Silver IRAs to be stored in an IRS-approved depository.
- New York has several reputable storage facilities, including private vaults and depositories such as Brink’s and IDS of New York.
- Purchasing Restrictions
- There are no restrictions on who can buy gold and silver in New York, but investors should only purchase from reputable dealers to avoid counterfeit products or scams.
- IRA Eligibility Rules
- Only specific types of gold and silver meet IRS standards for inclusion in a self-directed IRA. Gold must be at least 99.5% pure, and silver must be at least 99.9% pure.
How to Choose the Best Gold Dealer in New York
When selecting a gold dealer in New York, consider the following factors:
- Reputation and Reviews
- Look for dealers with strong customer ratings and accreditation from the Better Business Bureau (BBB).
- Pricing Transparency
- Ensure the dealer provides clear, upfront pricing without hidden fees.
- Investment Options
- Choose a dealer that offers a variety of gold and silver bullion, coins, and IRA-eligible metals.
- Customer Service
- Opt for a dealer with knowledgeable staff and excellent customer support.
- Storage and Security
- Verify that the dealer partners with IRS-approved depositories for secure storage of IRA metals.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q: Is gold taxable in New York? A: Gold purchases under $1,000 are subject to sales tax, but investment-grade bullion purchases above this threshold are tax-exempt.
Q: Where can I store my gold in New York? A: Investors can store gold at home, in a private vault, or in an IRS-approved depository like Brink’s or IDS of New York for Gold IRAs.
Q: How do I verify a gold dealer’s credibility? A: Check BBB ratings, read customer reviews, and ensure they provide transparent pricing and secure transactions.
Q: Can I include gold and silver in an IRA? A: Yes, but only IRS-approved gold and silver bullion meeting specific purity requirements can be included in a self-directed IRA.
Attention: Are You Gambling with Your Retirement?
Inflation is eroding the value of your hard-earned dollars, and the stock market feels more like a roll of the dice. But here’s the truth: you can take control of your financial future with a Gold IRA.
Gold isn’t a gamble—it’s proven. For centuries, gold has been a foundation of wealth and stability. It’s real. It’s reliable. It’s the opposite of leaving your future to chance.
Take action today:
- Claim the best offer below
- Or click here to explore our Best Gold IRA Companies list and discover how smart investors are securing their futures.
Your financial security isn’t something to “hope” for—it’s something you can guarantee. Get your FREE Gold IRA Kit now and start protecting what you’ve worked so hard to build.
Your future self will thank you.
Click the button below to get a free gold kit from Augusta Precious Metals, our #1 ranked Gold IRA company.
Conclusion
New York offers a variety of reputable gold dealers for investors looking to buy bullion or roll over their retirement accounts into Gold IRAs. Augusta Precious Metals leads the list due to its transparency and investor education, while Lear Capital excels in price transparency. Preserve Gold stands out for customer service, and Noble Gold is a great option for beginners. Additionally, local bullion dealers in New York provide excellent in-person buying options. By evaluating your needs and choosing a trusted dealer, you can confidently invest in gold for long-term financial security.
